FINAL OFFICIAL
Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners Minutes
SPECIAL MEETING
Wednesday, August 13, 2025
9:30:00 AM
Commission Chambers
Disclaimer Minutes Definitions    

Members Present: Oliver G. Gilbert, III; Keon Hardemon; Natalie Milian Orbis; Raquel A. Regalado; Danielle Cohen Higgins; Kionne L. McGhee; Anthony Rodriguez; Roberto J. Gonzalez; Sen. Rene Garcia
Members Absent: None
Members Late: None
Members Excused: Marleine Bastien; Micky Steinberg; Eileen Higgins; Juan Carlos Bermudez
Members Absent County Business: None

         
1 MINUTES PREPARED BY:  
  REPORT: Flora Garcia, Commission Reporter
(305) 375-4906
 
1A INVOCATION AS PROVIDED IN RULE 5.05(H)  
  REPORT: Commissioner Gonzalez led the invocation.  
1B ROLL CALL  
  REPORT: Chairman Rodriguez convened the Board of County Commissioners' (Board) Special meeting at 9:51 a.m.

In addition to the Board members and Mayor Daniella Levine Cava, the following staff members were present:

- County Attorney (CA) Geri Bonzon-Keenan;
- Mr. Jimmy Morales, Chief Operations Officer, Office of the Mayor;
- Dr. Carladenise Edwards, Chief Administrative Officer, Office of the Mayor;
- Ms. Namita Uppal, Director, Strategic Procurement Department (SPD);
- Ms. Ofelia Tamayo, Director, Internal Compliance Department (ICD); and
- Deputy Clerks Basia Pruna, Kerry Khunjar Breakenridge and Flora Garcia

Also in attendance were Honorable Clerk Juan Fernandez-Barquin, Clerk of the Court and Comptroller of Miami-Dade County, and Miami-Dade Property Appraiser Tomas Regalado.

MOTION TO SET THE AGENDA

CA Geri Bonzon-Keenan announced there were no changes to today's agenda.

Commissioner Gilbert III moved that the Board approve the agenda as presented. Commissioner Gonzalez seconded the motion; and upon being put to a vote, the motion passed 7-0 (Vice Chairman McGhee, and Commissioners Bastien, Bermudez, Higgins, Milian Orbis, and Steinberg were absent).
 
1C PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE  
  REPORT: Commissioner Cohen Higgins led the Pledge of Allegiance.  
 
SPECIAL ITEM(S)  
Special Item No. 1  
  251524 Resolution   Click here if you don't have Adobe PDF Reader Clerk's Official Copy    Oliver G. Gilbert, III        
  RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING REJECTION OF ALL PROPOSALS RECEIVED IN RESPONSE TO THE COMPETITIVE SOLICITATION AND WAIVER OF COMPETITIVE BIDDING PROCEDURES PURSUANT TO SECTION 5.03(D) OF THE HOME RULE CHARTER AND SECTION 2-8.1(B) OF THE COUNTY CODE, BY A TWO-THIRDS VOTE OF THE BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT, AND AWARD A NON-COMPETITIVE CONTRACT, CONTRACT NO. EVN0004282, SELF-FUNDED EMPLOYEE GROUP HEALTHCARE PROGRAM, TO AETNA LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY IN AN AMOUNT ESTIMATED TO BE $77,676,808.00 FOR A FIVE-YEAR TERM WITH ONE, TWO-YEAR OPTION TO RENEW FOR THE PEOPLE AND INTERNAL OPERATIONS DEPARTMENT; AND AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY MAYOR OR COUNTY MAYOR�S DESIGNEE TO EXECUTE THE AGREEMENT AND EXERCISE ALL PROVISIONS OF THE CONTRACT, INCLUDING ANY CANCELLATION, RENEWAL, OR EXTENSIONS, PURSUANT TO SECTION 2-8.1 OF THE COUNTY CODE AND IMPLEMENTING ORDER 3-38(Strategic Procurement) Adopted
Resolution R-803-25
Mover: Sen. Rene Garcia
Seconder: Oliver G. Gilbert, III
Vote: 7 - 2
No: Cohen Higgins , Gonzalez
Excused: Bastien , Steinberg , Higgins , Bermudez
  REPORT: Commissioner Gilbert III announced that members of TWU and AFSCME Locals 199 and 3292 attended the meeting to support awarding the healthcare contract to Aetna Life Insurance Company (Aetna).


Chairman Rodriguez opened the discussion and invited Aon Consulting (Aon) to present its independent analysis.


Ms. Uppal explained the procurement process and referred to the Board's directive from July 16, 2025, which called for contracting an additional independent consultant to analyze the healthcare bills, claims, and proposal data with the goal of identifying which company, Aetna or AvMed, would be less expensive for the County. She highlighted that Aon was selected through an expedited process based on its reputation and its role as the State of Florida's consultant, to ensure that the work could begin as soon as possible.


Chairman Rodriguez asked whether changing the administrator would affect employee benefits and whether employees' doctors would accept the new carrier.


Ms. Uppal affirmed that employee benefits would not be compromised, since the County was self-insured and responsible for designing its own healthcare plan. She emphasized that the Request for Proposal (RFP) kept the plan design, including benefits negotiated with labor unions, unchanged. She noted that the County's current provider network matched AvMed at approximately 89% and Aetna at 99%.


Ms. Emily Naples, Aon's Assistant Vice President and lead consultant, provided a brief overview of her professional background.


Ms. Amanda Brooks, Aon's Lead Actuary overseeing all Florida public sector clients, shared an overview of her professional experience. She noted that Aon was contracted immediately following the Board meeting of July 21, 2025, received all documentation related to the RFP, including the proposals, repriced claims data, Best and Final Offer (BAFO) proposals, and addenda, on July 22, 2025, interviewed each vendor on July 24, 2025, and sent a memorandum outlining its findings to Dr. Edwards on July 29, 2025.

Ms. Brooks explained the analysis process. She indicated that Aon reviewed the repriced medical claims and fees incurred and paid between January and December 2023, compared the billed charges to the allowed amounts, and backed into each vendor's discount rate. She stated that the analysis revealed Aetna's medical claims and fees were $45.5 million lower than AvMed's. She further explained the differences in how the two vendors applied their discounts. Ms. Brooks highlighted that Aetna had nearly $6 million in initially excluded claims, which was typical for a non-incumbent carrier responding to an RFP due to coding variations. She noted that approximately $4 million of the $6 million in excluded claims was included in the total claims analyzed, calculated at an estimated average discount rate of 68%.


Chairman Rodriguez asked what the savings would be if the excluded claims were removed entirely and whether Aon had reviewed the contracts.


Ms. Brooks confirmed that the projected savings would be approximately $40 million without the excluded claims and that Aon's sensitivity testing did not change the outcome. She clarified that Aon's engagement was limited to the medical claims and fees and did not include a review of the contracts.


Chairman Rodriguez asked the Administration to confirm on the record whether the contract held the provider accountable for the savings presented.


Dr. Edwards stated that the contract's language included guarantees for the offered cost savings and services.


Senator Garcia inquired how the discounts were applied, whether the contract was fee-for-service or capitated, and whether the bills were already discounted when they reached the County.


Ms. Brooks explained that either vendor would charge the County a monthly fee per employee or member, regardless of the number of claims submitted, and that the discount rates were based on each vendor's negotiated rates with its contracted providers. She noted that Aetna offered a national network at no additional cost. She also clarified the concept of capitated services and how those services were evaluated, noting that Aetna did not capitate any services, so those services were included in its repriced claims.


Commissioner Regalado requested that the term "claims" be referred to as "bills," as the County is self-insured and the word "claims" has a different legal connotation. She also asked how Aon's methodology differed from Gallagher's.


Ms. Brooks stated that, to her knowledge, both consulting firms received the same data for analysis. She mentioned that she could not discuss the differences between the two analyses because the County directed Aon to conduct its work without reviewing Gallagher's analysis, so that the Board would have two independent evaluations.


Chairman Rodriguez invited Aetna's representatives to give a presentation.


Ms. Kathy Aguirre, Aetna's Vice President of Client Management for the Public and Labor Division in the Southeast Region, introduced the following Aetna representatives:

- Mr. John Cantillo, Financial Director of Underwriting
- Ms. Renthia Jackson, Vice President of Client Management
- Dr. Washington, clinical representative

Ms. Aguirre presented a PowerPoint on Aetna's scale, experience, and repricing results, noting that Aetna's repricing yielded a 71.5% discount and that a custom discount secured with a major local health system supported a guaranteed rate of 73%.


Mr. Cantillo explained Aetna's 2026 cost projection, which applied AvMed's 14% year-over-year trend to reach 2025 and committed that 2026 costs would be no more than 5% above 2025.


Ms. Jackson described Aetna's transition readiness, including an open enrollment hotline, transition-of-care protocols, provider outreach for the less than 1% of doctors not in network, and national network access.


Chairman Rodriguez invited AvMed's representatives to give a presentation.


Mr. Mike Llorente, LSN Law, appeared on behalf of AvMed and introduced Mr. Colin Drozdowski, President of Sentara, AvMed's parent company; Ms. Stacy Fuqua, President of AvMed; Mr. Frankie Schierto, Vice President of Provider Network; Ms. Candy Sickel, Vice President of Sales; and Dr. Eric Johnson, Chief Actuary.

Mr. Llorente argued that the County was being asked to terminate a $4 billion procurement won by AvMed and to replace the proposers' submitted prices with consultant-generated figures. He noted that Aetna's own price proposal projected $503 million in 2026 medical claims, while Gallagher's analysis of the same repriced claims produced $345 million, a $157 million gap that was never reconciled, and he contended that the price swap was prohibited under the RFP's rules.


Dr. Johnson presented AvMed's analysis of the County's four-year claims history, projecting a 2026 run rate of approximately $440 million, within a reasonable range of $420 million to $460 million, and AvMed's proposed $426 million. He stated that neither Aetna's $503 million projection nor Gallagher's $345 million figure was reasonable relative to history, that the $345 million figure would unwind four years of medical inflation, and that a $157 million annual variance over the life of the contract would amount to a $1.1 billion mistake. He urged the Board not to accept a rushed and flawed procurement.


Chairman Rodriguez commented that the Board had to rely on its consultants, that he had questioned both consultants extensively, and that nobody on the dais wanted to make a $1.1 billion mistake during a year of significant budget deficit.


Commissioner Regalado suggested getting feedback from the Constitutional Officers.


Chairman Rodriguez announced that the Office of the Sheriff had sent a letter supporting the selection of Aetna as the County's healthcare administrator.


Senator Garcia highlighted AvMed's strengths and its 45-year history of successfully serving the County. However, he recommended awarding the contract to Aetna, noting Aon's verification of the $45 million in savings and Aetna's capacity to negotiate better rates through the economies of scale of its more extensive network. He cautioned that the transition would not be seamless.

Senator Garcia moved that the Board adopt Special Item No. 1 to reject all proposals received in response to the advertised competitive solicitation and award the non-competitive Contract No. EVN0004282 to Aetna Life Insurance Company as the County's healthcare administrator. The motion was seconded, and the floor was opened for discussion.


Chairman Rodriguez welcomed Clerk Fernandez-Barquin and Property Appraiser Regalado and noted that both indicated a preference for Aetna.


Clerk Fernandez-Barquin expressed his support for whichever provider offered the best cost-benefit analysis, which he understood to be Aetna.


Property Appraiser Regalado recommended that the healthcare contract be awarded to Aetna for the benefit of the County's employees.


Commissioner Gonzalez thanked Chairman Rodriguez for his leadership and expressed appreciation to Ms. Uppal and to the Aetna and AvMed teams for answering his questions. He highlighted the need to establish a cost-efficient healthcare plan that did not compromise employees' health and well-being, stressing the importance of fiscal responsibility. He explained that he had invoked the 4-Day Rule on this item because of the unease among employees, and he noted the lack of trust surrounding the process. To assure employees that every speaker was bound to truthfulness, he referenced Florida Statute Section 837.06, relating to false official statements, and the Citizens' Bill of Rights in the Miami-Dade County Home Rule Charter.

Commissioner Gonzalez asked the Administration to explain why the award was being processed as a bid waiver, whether any discussions with the providers preceded the RFP, and why the item came before the Board at such a late date.


Ms. Uppal explained that the selection committee ranked Aetna first and AvMed second; that the Board's local preference rules entitled AvMed, as a local firm within 5% of the top score, to an opportunity to negotiate first; and that she requested Best and Final Offers from both firms in parallel rather than sequentially, which the County Attorney opined converted the award into a bid waiver.


Dr. Edwards added that the County had determined AvMed's pricing was out of market and spent approximately 18 months negotiating for better pricing in hopes of securing an extension before issuing the RFP. She noted that the contract had last been procured in 2008.


Commissioner Gonzalez asked what the County was purchasing, what savings the Administration expected, how the consultants arrived at their figures, and when the savings would be realized.


Dr. Edwards explained that the County was purchasing third-party administrative services for its self-funded healthcare program. She recapped the claims and payment processes and confirmed that the consultants analyzed actual 2023 claims data provided by the County, which both proposers repriced line by line. She emphasized that, based on Aetna's proven claims experience and the pre-negotiated rates with its network of doctors, the bills submitted to the County would be as low as possible. Dr. Edwards stated that Aetna would achieve savings through its provider network and implement programs and services to bend the cost curve, so that the County would save money over time. She estimated the savings at approximately $45.5 million based on Aon's analysis.


Chairman Rodriguez noted that the Finance Director had previously advised him that savings would not be realized until FY 2026-27 and asked Dr. Edwards to clarify.


Commissioner Gonzalez asked whether the savings were already accounted for in the proposed budget and, if so, how they would be used.


Dr. Edwards clarified that the $45 million in claims savings would be realized over time and was not included in the FY 2025-26 budget. She explained that the proposed budget instead reduced the departments' per-employee contribution for health coverage by approximately $17 million to relieve pressure on the general fund, which did not change the amount employees paid and did not depend on which provider was selected.


Commissioner Gilbert III offered a point of information, noting that the County is legally required to adopt a balanced budget, that the $17 million reduction in administrative cost applied regardless of the provider selected, and that the $45 million in claims savings was a separate amount that would be realized over time.


Commissioner Gonzalez asked whether the proposers had an opportunity to review or dispute the consultants' figures.


Ms. Aguirre stated that the RFP's cone of silence did not permit discussions outside the procurement process.


Dr. Johnson stated that AvMed received the claims data but was not given an opportunity to address discrepancies before the analysis was presented to the Administration. He stated that AvMed did not agree with the consultants' findings, explaining that both consultants calculated AvMed's discount at approximately 65% while AvMed's actual reported discount was 70%, and that each percentage point represented approximately $10 million. He attributed the difference to the consultants' treatment of AvMed's multi-tiered networks, including the Select and Jackson First networks, and stated that applying AvMed's correct discount would erase $40 million to $50 million from the consultants' projected AvMed cost.


Ms. Uppal noted that both firms answered the selection committee's questions and met with Aon at the Board's direction. She added that the same repricing methodology and consultant were used in the 2008 and 2015 procurements, both of which AvMed won.


Dr. Edwards stated that even using AvMed's 69% figure against Aetna's 71%, a $20 million difference remained.


Commissioner Gonzalez asked whether the award would require reopening the collective bargaining agreements, whether the Constitutional Officers were included in the savings analysis, and what protections the County would have if Aetna failed to deliver.


Dr. Edwards clarified that it was unnecessary to reopen the union bargaining agreements to approve the proposed award. She explained the structure of the employees' and the County's contributions, noting that the employees' contributions for the 2026 enrollment period would remain unchanged under the labor union contracts in effect, and that the County would have the opportunity to revisit the benefit structure when the agreements were reopened. She highlighted that, by law, the County was required to maintain a balance in the healthcare trust fund to cover unanticipated claims, and she recommended that the trust fund be fully funded. She confirmed that all Constitutional Officers remained in the County's plan for FY 2025-26 and that Aetna's national network with guaranteed rates would not be affected if any Constitutional Officer opted out. She stated that the contract included guarantees and termination clauses if the provider failed to meet them.


Vice Chairman McGhee asked whether the savings had been accounted for in the proposed budget.


Dr. Edwards reiterated that the proposed FY 2025-26 budget did not account for the projected $45 million savings from the County's claims; however, the departments' administrative costs had been reduced in the proposed budget.


Commissioner Gonzalez asked whether the contract contained a liquidated damages clause and what the penalty would be.


Ms. Uppal explained that the contract included a payment corridor, which would require the provider to make payments back to the County if the guaranteed percentages were not met.


Dr. Edwards read the guarantee clause into the record, stating that it required the provider to reimburse the County for any amount due or reduce future administrative fees by the amount due, and reserved the County's right to revise, remove, amend, or terminate the contract.


Commissioner Gonzalez and Senator Garcia asked Aetna to confirm on the record whether it was guaranteeing the savings.


Mr. Cantillo affirmed that Aetna was guaranteeing a discount rate of 73%, which exceeded the rates calculated by Aon and Gallagher.


Commissioner Gonzalez stated that he had not seen the guarantee in the contract and asked that it be provided in writing.


Chairman Rodriguez also asked to see the guarantee in writing, noting that he had been assured it was in the contract.


Mr. Llorente countered that Aetna was guaranteeing a discount rate, not savings, and that AvMed had offered essentially the same discount guarantee. He stated that AvMed's actual 2023 medical claims totaled $365 million, nearly identical to the $369 million Aetna's repricing would have produced for 2023, and that the consultants' assumption of a 65% discount for AvMed, rather than its most recently reported 69.9%, created the illusory $40 million in savings.


Chairman Rodriguez asked whether AvMed would guarantee the 69.9% discount rate.


Dr. Johnson confirmed that AvMed would guarantee that rate and had done so in its RFP response.


Commissioner Gilbert III characterized the debate as theater, noting that each vendor and its lobbyists were paid to advocate their position while the County had paid two consultants to analyze the data, both of which found savings with Aetna. He explained the cost savings and the timeframe in which the County would realize them, and noted that the selection committee, the Administration, the two consultants, the Constitutional Officers heard from, and the unions all supported Aetna. He cautioned that the Sheriff opting out of the County's plan would be a catastrophe.


Commissioner Regalado commented that the coverage questions she received from hundreds of employees were decisions made by the County, not the provider, and that no one's coverage would change as a result of the award. She noted that the analysis and memoranda did not address retirees, many of whom live outside the County and would be affected by a national network. She asked both providers how they worked with Jackson Health System, which the County's residents subsidize.


Dr. Johnson described AvMed's Jackson First plan, which was designed to steer utilization to Jackson, AvMed's lower negotiated rates at Jackson, and its care and disease management programs.


Ms. Aguirre stated that Aetna was asked to match the Jackson steerage in all benefit designs and would wrap its national network around the Jackson network.


Dr. Washington described Aetna's population health management, gap-closure programs, and potential collaborations with Jackson.


Commissioner Regalado asked that the Administration have the administrator work with Jackson to give Jackson participants more options. She also asked what plan was in place for patients in active treatment whose doctors were not in Aetna's network.


Ms. Aguirre explained the transition-of-care process, noting that Aetna would load an authorization so the member could continue treatment while Aetna pursued a contract with the provider.


Commissioner Cohen Higgins voiced concerns about deciding a $4 billion contract affecting 30,000 employees without committee review, during August recess, in a rushed process. She noted that the Board's 2023 resolution required RFPs for contracts of this type to be on the street no later than 12 months before contract expiration, and that this RFP was issued in January 2025. She asked Aetna why it provided projections only for 2026 rather than through 2030 as the RFP requested.


Ms. Aguirre explained that the RFP contained only 2023 and 2024 data, that 2025 data was not available, and that only the incumbent could project forward.


Commissioner Cohen Higgins questioned why the two other proposers were deemed non-responsive for failing to submit cost data while Aetna was not.


CA Bonzon-Keenan explained that no responsiveness opinion was requested for Aetna's proposal because the Administration proceeded on a bid waiver basis.


Ms. Uppal noted that the two disqualified proposers submitted no cost data at all, including administrative services fees.


Commissioner Cohen Higgins further noted that the Board mandated oral presentations for procurements exceeding $25 million and read into the record an SPD email dated June 9, 2025, stating that the meeting that day was strictly for questions and answers and that there would be no presentations.


Ms. Uppal acknowledged the mandate and stated that the selection committee chose to ask the proposers clarifying questions.


Commissioner Cohen Higgins then turned to Gallagher's role, asking why Gallagher became involved after the selection committee scored the proposals and how the price differential between Aetna's $502 million projection and Gallagher's $345 million figure arose.


Ms. Barbara Crow, Gallagher Benefit Services, stated that Gallagher was involved from the drafting of the RFP, did not modify the scoring, and presented its repricing analysis to the selection committee before scoring.


Mr. Llorente stated that the RFP disclosed that Gallagher would analyze the financial information using a confidential and proprietary methodology, that AvMed objected before proposals were submitted, and that AvMed did not see Gallagher's analysis until after the recommendation was made.


Gallagher's actuary explained that, rather than rely on each vendor's unverifiable projection assumptions, Gallagher used only the 1.5 million actual 2023 claim records repriced by each vendor and rolled up the results without modification.


Commissioner Cohen Higgins questioned the appropriateness of consultants adjusting the proposers' submitted prices after the competitive process. She asked the consultants and both providers to reconcile the 65% discount rate attributed to AvMed with AvMed's reported 69.9%, and whether a 69.9% rate would change the savings analysis.


Ms. Crow and Gallagher's actuary stated that the 65% figure resulted from rolling up AvMed's own repricing data, and that a 69.9% rate would reduce the projected savings, although a savings would remain at 69% versus Aetna's 71%.


Ms. Brooks agreed that a 69.9% discount would change the savings analysis if reflected in the repriced claims.


Mr. Llorente and Dr. Johnson stated that the numbers could not be reconciled and that AvMed's actual 2023 paid claims of $365 million aligned with the 69% figure. Mr. Llorente stated that AvMed guaranteed 73% with a 2% corridor.


Mr. Cantillo stated that Aetna agreed with the consultants' analysis, that AvMed's initial discount guarantee was 67% before Gallagher's results were released, and that the repricing was the verifiable basis for comparison.


Ms. Aguirre stated that Aetna guaranteed 73% with a 1% corridor and confirmed that the discount applied to seniors and to the national network.


Both providers confirmed that their discount-guarantee exclusions were identical.


Commissioner Cohen Higgins concluded that the guaranteed rates and exclusions were the same, that the procurement process was flawed, and that she needed more than one year of projected savings to support a $4 billion decision.


Chairman Rodriguez read into the record a letter from Tax Collector Dario Fernandez and a message from Supervisor of Elections Alina Garcia, both supporting Aetna.


Vice Chairman McGhee asked for clarification on the 6,000 excluded claims referenced earlier.


Ms. Brooks clarified that approximately $6 million in claims, not 6,000 claims, were initially excluded from Aetna's repricing, and that Aon included just over $4 million of that amount at a conservative 68% discount.


Commissioner Milian Orbis noted that she had been enrolled with AvMed for nearly 20 years as a County employee and asked about the cost of implementing the change in INFORMS and the system's readiness.


Ms. Uppal advised that the programming cost would be minimal.


Dr. Edwards stated that the team was on standby to reprogram the system regardless of which provider was selected.


Ms. Tamayo affirmed that the implementation team, including the Office of Enterprise Strategies, the Information Technology Department, and Human Resources, was ready and awaited the Board's decision, noting that the timeline would be tight.


Commissioner Milian Orbis asked when the transition plan would begin, when employees would have access to the provider list, and when exempt employees would gain access to the national network.


Ms. Uppal stated that the transition plan would begin the day the Board made its decision, notwithstanding a pending injunction, and that employees would have access to the national network when the contract began on January 1, 2026, while the four existing plan designs remained subject to the bargaining agreements.


Dr. Edwards clarified that the administrative services contract would begin upon execution and that benefits under the new plan would begin January 1, 2026, following open enrollment.


Commissioner Milian Orbis asked the Administration to proactively confirm employees' doctors before January 1, 2026.


Ms. Uppal agreed and noted that no doctor checked to date had been found outside Aetna's network.


Commissioner Gonzalez stated that the situation could have been avoided with more time and transparency, and that employees did not trust the process. He asked Aetna to guarantee on the record that employees with existing medical conditions, including cancer patients, expectant mothers, and patients using durable medical equipment, would continue treatment without interruption.


Chairman Rodriguez stated that it was important that the answers be placed on the record and in the contract so employees would be assured of no lapse in coverage.


Ms. Jackson advised that State law governed transition of care for patients in active treatment, and that Aetna would honor those obligations, including for pregnancies, chemotherapy, grandfathered drugs, and durable medical equipment. She confirmed that dependents attending college outside Florida would have access to Aetna's national network without separate enrollment.


Commissioner Gonzalez asked AvMed to address rumors that retirees would lose their Medicare coverage.


Ms. Sickel stated that AvMed would not participate in Medicare in 2026, but that Retiree First would continue to administer retiree benefits; that 77% of post-65 retirees were enrolled in a Medicare Supplement plan that was not changing; and that the 22% enrolled in AvMed's Medicare Advantage prescription drug plan would be assisted in selecting a new plan.


Ms. Jackson stated that Aetna guaranteed to provide what retirees have today and more.


Senator Garcia spoke in support of awarding the contract to Aetna because Aetna had a more robust national network that benefited employees and retirees and would still produce savings even at the discount rates AvMed cited. He called the question.


Commissioner Gilbert III commented that he did not distrust the Mayor or the Administration and believed they were right in this instance, that two consultants confirmed the Administration's recommendation, and that he had chosen Aetna for his own family through another plan. He stated that the decision was not difficult, only big, and that for AvMed to be right everyone else would have to be wrong.


Vice Chairman McGhee stated that the process was flawed and the Board should have had more time. He attributed the outcome to AvMed's decision to negotiate from a position of leverage during the 18 months of negotiations with the Administration; and as a result, he could not feel sympathy for AvMed and would support contracting with Aetna.


Chairman Rodriguez noted that AvMed indicated the negotiation timeline described was not accurate. He clarified that a yes vote would adopt the Administration's recommendation to approve the bid waiver and award the contract to Aetna, and a no vote would reject the item.


Hearing no further discussion, the Board proceeded to vote on the foregoing proposed resolution as presented. Hearing no further discussion, the Board proceeded to vote on the foregoing proposed resolution as presented.


Commissioner Regalado advised of her intent to bring an item addressing healthcare coverage for neurodivergent individuals, including autistic adults and persons with dementia and Alzheimer's disease, specifically sedation for dentistry, adult daycare, and behavioral therapies, and she asked that the item not be subject to the full committee process so the Board could act at its next meeting and include the coverages in the 2026 open enrollment.


Chairman Rodriguez directed that the request be shown as a directive to the County Administration to report the costs of the requested coverages at the next Board meeting.


Dr. Edwards accepted the directive and stated that, while she could not commit to having the coverages in place for open enrollment, the Administration would return with the costs and options.


Commissioner Milian Orbis asked that the County Administration include in the report options for in vitro fertilization treatments.


Chairman Rodriguez asked that the County Administration also report on all coverages currently excluded from the plan that affect more than a small percentage of employees.


Dr. Edwards stated that the report would include a menu of options and associated costs for the services employees had asked to have incorporated in the healthcare plan, and that she would meet with each commissioner individually to gather additional requests. She emphasized that the County, as the insurer, decides what the plan covers, and the administrator manages the costs.


Commissioner Regalado added that covering dental sedation and adult daycare would produce savings by avoiding costlier hospital sedation and at-home care.
 
  7/16/2025 4 Day Rule Invoked by the Board of County Commissioners  
Special Item No. 1 Suppl  
  251610 Supplement      
  SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION REGARDING RECOMMENDATION TO AWARD A CONTRACT FOR SELF-FUNDED EMPLOYEE GROUP HEALTHCARE PROGRAM - LEGISTAR NO. 251524 Presented
15F1  
  251581 Report      
  ALLOCATION OF FISCAL YEAR (FY) 2024-2025 DISTRICT DESIGNATED FUNDS (D13) TO SKY HOMES IMPROVEMENT, LLC Approved
Mover: Sen. Rene Garcia
Seconder: Raquel A. Regalado
Vote: 9 - 0
Excused: Bastien , Steinberg , Higgins , Bermudez
  REPORT: Senator Garcia corrected the funding allocation recipient�s name from Sky Home Improvements, Inc., to Sky Homes Improvement, LLC, for the funding allocation made at the Board meeting held on July 16, 2025.  
  7/16/2025 Approved by the Board of County Commissioners  
ADJOURNMENT  
  REPORT: There being no further business to come before the Board, the meeting was adjourned at 1:16 p.m.  
3 CONSENT AGENDA  
 


11/19/2026       Agenda Key: 5306

Home  |   Agendas  |   Minutes  |   Legislative Search  |   Lobbyist Registration  |   Legislative Reports
2026 BCC Meeting Calendar  |   Miami-Dade County Code of Ordinances   |   ADA Notice  |  

Home  |  Using Our Site  |  About  |  Phone Directory  |  Privacy  |  Disclaimer

E-mail your comments, questions and suggestions to Webmaster  

Web Site � 2026 Miami-Dade County.
All rights reserved.